Can I Collect My Own Evidence to Use If My Child Custody Case Goes to Court? | Indiana Child Custody Lawyers

When navigating the emotional and intricate path of child custody battles, a crucial query we often encounter from clients is: “Can I collect my own evidence for the case?” As experienced Indiana child custody attorneys, our answer is nuanced, “You may, depending on the circumstances.”

It’s not uncommon for parents, while embroiled in these disputes, to first turn to friends and family for counsel. While comforting, these personal conversations might not always offer the legal clarity needed for court proceedings. This is where an Indiana child custody lawyer truly shines.

If you are facing a child custody dispute in Indiana, we invite you to call our office at 812-944-8005 to schedule a consultation. We can listen to the facts of your case, explain your legal options, and tenaciously fight for the best outcome possible. We also encourage you to read through the following FAQs to learn more about evidence collection in Indiana child custody matters.

Man spying on someone with binoculars

Indiana Child Custody Evidence FAQs

Can my personal account be foundational to my child custody case in Indiana?

Undoubtedly. Keeping a meticulous journal detailing any questionable actions or events involving the other parent can be invaluable. This journal serves several pivotal roles:

  1. Declaration Foundation. Your Indiana child custody attorney can craft a compelling declaration—a sworn statement outlining events reinforcing your perspective. Detailed journal entries significantly enhance this declaration’s weight before the judge.
  2. Witness Highlighting. This log assists in identifying potential witnesses, pivotal if they’ve directly observed relevant incidents. Their testimonies, backed by the specific legal norms of Indiana, can fortify your case.
  3. Aiding Recall. Over time, recollection can blur. Your journal aids in refreshing memories during testimonies.


Can I utilize written communication as evidence with the help of my child custody lawyer?

Absolutely. Any written interactions, be it emails, texts, or social media exchanges, that might fortify your stance should be shared with your Indiana child custody attorney. Even if deemed hearsay, these records may find acceptance in Indiana courts. Yet, exercise caution with your personal communications—they can be used against you in legal battles.

What types of evidence should I collect for my Indiana child custody case?

Navigating a child custody case in Indiana requires careful preparation and strategy. If you’re looking to bolster your position, gathering and presenting the right evidence is vital. Here’s a list of potential evidence types you should consider collecting for your Indiana child custody case:

  • Personal Journal/Logs. Maintain a detailed journal of interactions, incidents, and any concerning behaviors of the other parent. Note dates, times, locations, and any witnesses.
  • Written Communication. Collect and preserve emails, text messages, letters, and social media messages between you and the other parent or those that reference your child and the parenting situation.
  • Photographs/Videos. Any visual documentation showing the living conditions of both households, interactions with your child, or events can be helpful.
  • Financial Records. Documentation of child support payments, medical expenses, school fees, or any other financial contributions towards your child’s well-being.
  • Medical Records. Any relevant health documentation showing regular check-ups, medical treatments, or other healthcare provisions.
  • Educational Records. Report cards, attendance records, teacher’s notes, or emails showing your child’s performance and well-being in school.
  • Character Witnesses. Statements or testimonies from individuals like teachers, counselors, neighbors, or family friends who can vouch for your parenting skills and your child’s well-being under your care.
  • Child’s Writings or Artworks. Sometimes, children’s feelings and experiences can be reflected in their drawings, writings, or other expressive creations. While interpretations can be subjective, they may provide insight into a child’s state of mind.
  • Visitation Logs. If there’s an existing visitation arrangement, maintain logs of missed, delayed, or rescheduled visits by the other parent.
  • Professional Assessments. Reports or testimonies from child psychologists, counselors, or therapists, if the child has been attending sessions.
  • Private Investigator Reports. Especially if you suspect misconduct or inappropriate behavior from the other parent, a private investigator can provide authenticated reports and findings.
  • Law Enforcement or Protective Services Records. If there have been any incidents requiring police intervention or Child Protective Services involvement, procure these records.
  • Rehabilitation or Therapy Records. If applicable, documentation proving that you’ve taken steps to address personal issues, such as addiction or anger management.
  • Parenting Classes. Certificates or evidence that you’ve taken parenting courses, which can show your commitment to providing the best for your child.
  • Hearsay Exceptions. Though hearsay is generally inadmissible, some exceptions, like spontaneous statements or particular records, might be admissible. As Indiana child custody attorneys with decades of experience, we can guide you on these nuances.

It’s essential to remember that while collecting evidence, respect privacy laws and avoid any invasive or unethical actions that could negatively impact your case. Engaging an experienced Indiana child custody attorney can provide clarity on the types of evidence most pertinent to your specific situation and ensure your case is presented in the best light.

Are Medical or Educational Documents Viable Evidence in Indiana?

Such records can be instrumental. However, due to hearsay regulations, they might not be directly admissible. However, by collaborating with an Indiana child custody lawyer, you can strategize by having the document’s issuer, say a doctor or educator, testify.  It’s vital to note, involving external witnesses can elevate expenses. As an alternative, having declarations from potential witnesses in the initial stages can be beneficial.

Schedule A Consultation with an Experienced Indiana Child Custody Lawyer Today!

Journeying through a child custody case requires both emotional resilience and strategic acumen. While self-gathered evidence can be beneficial, its strategic presentation by an Indiana child custody attorney can make all the difference. With Mattox & Wilson, you’re not only armed with evidence but a dedicated team to present it most effectively, ensuring your genuine love and commitment to your child is undeniably visible to the courts. Call our office today to schedule a consultation to learn more about our outstanding child custody representation.

Pay Bill Pay Retainer