Indiana School Choice Dispute Attorneys: Navigating School Disputes

Even with the best advice and resources available, arriving at a unified decision regarding the best interests and educational needs of a child can be challenging for parents. When such discord arises, and attempts at resolution prove unsuccessful, we may advise our clients to consider mediation or the aid of a parenting coordinator. However, if these options do not yield a resolution, it may be necessary to turn to the courts and allow a judge to determine the child’s best interests.

Two young schoolchildren in private school uniforms

As experienced attorneys at Mattox & Wilson, we understand how stressful and challenging school choice disputes can be. If you, as a parent, find yourself in the midst of such a dispute, we want you to know that you are not alone. We are here to help. We invite you to call our office today to schedule a consultation. In this meeting, we will provide comprehensive information about your rights under Indiana law and discuss the best possible strategies to protect your interests and those of your child. We believe in fostering understanding and empowering our clients, and we’re ready to provide the support and guidance you need during this challenging time. Don’t wait; reach out to us today.

School Choice Disputes In The Context of Joint Legal Custody

As experienced child custody attorneys at Mattox & Wilson, we’ve dealt extensively with the intricate nuances of joint legal custody. One crucial topic within the ambit of joint legal custody that often comes into dispute is the choice of school for the child.

Joint legal custody necessitates a certain level of cooperation and agreement between parents. As mandated by law, parents with joint legal custody are expected to jointly decide on matters pertaining to the child’s schooling, religious upbringing, and healthcare. In other words, if you and your ex-spouse share joint legal custody, it is essential that you communicate effectively about your child’s school choice before finalizing any decision.

What Can I Do If I Can’t Agree on School Arrangements With My Ex-Spouse?

In the event you and your ex-partner can’t come to an agreement, a court intervention might become necessary. This could lead to a potential modification of the custody arrangement to sole legal custody, empowering a single parent to make independent educational decisions. Alternatively, the court might issue a specific order solely addressing the school choice issue.

Indiana courts, when deliberating on matters related to a child’s education, refer to what is known as the ‘best interest standard’. Factors such as the quality and location of the school, any special needs of the child, the child’s existing connections to a particular school, and available aftercare options at different schools are typically taken into consideration.

If Private School Is In The Best Interests of My Child, Who Has To Pay For Private School Tuition?

One crucial issue that can arise, particularly when it is decided by the parents, a parenting coordinator, or the court, that private schooling is in a child’s best interests, is the question of who pays for this education. The costs for private schooling are typically allocated based on the parents’ respective incomes, mirroring the division used in child support calculations.[1] This generally involves a pro-rata percentage division similar to that used for uninsured medical expenses.

How Can An Experienced Child Custody Attorney Help Address School Choice Disputes?

An experienced Indiana child custody attorney can play a vital role in resolving school choice disputes. Here’s how:

  • Deep Knowledge of Law: We can provide a thorough understanding of Indiana family law, specifically around child custody and education decisions.
  • Experienced Guidance: We can guide you through the complexities of the legal process, explaining the ‘best interest standard’ and other legal principles the court uses to make decisions. Further, as experienced school dispute lawyers, we can also advise on potential outcomes based on prior cases and our professional experience.
  • Strong Representation: We can tenaciously represent you effectively in court, making compelling arguments on your behalf and ensuring your position is presented in the best light.
  • Negotiation and Mediation: We can help facilitate discussions and negotiations with the other parent. If necessary, we can recommend or arrange for a mediator or parenting coordinator to help find a resolution.
  • Support with Enforcement or Modification: If there’s a need to enforce or modify an existing custody order regarding school choice, our dedicated team can handle the legal processes required.
  • Child’s Best Interest: Above all, we have a deep understanding of how to frame arguments and make decisions that reflect the best interests of a child, which is the primary concern in any custody dispute.

If you’re dealing with a school choice dispute, the attorneys at Mattox & Wilson can provide the guidance and support you need.

Schedule A Consultation With An Experienced Indiana School Choice Attorney Today!

Facing a disagreement over school choice can be emotionally taxing and legally complex. As your trusted Indiana school choice dispute attorneys, we are dedicated to protecting your rights and securing the best outcomes for your child. Don’t navigate this challenging situation alone. Call us today to schedule a consultation, and let’s discuss how we can assist you in protecting your parental rights and the best interests of your child.


[1] A judge may deviate from this amount and allocate tuition costs in a different manner.

Pay Bill Pay Retainer